News

Every April, investors scan mutual fund rankings to identify the past year’s top performers. The logic seems straightforward—choose the fund that delivered the highest returns and expect the same performance going forward. However, this approach is not just overly simplistic—it can be dangerously misleading. Mutual fund performance is inherently cyclical. A fund that leads the pack one year can easily fall behind the next, and vice versa. This is because market conditions, sector trends, investor behaviour and even fund manager decisions shift over time. Basing your investment decision solely on past rankings is like driving while looking only in the rearview mirror.

The problem with ranking-based investing

While it’s tempting to invest in the previous year’s No. 1 fund, doing so is akin to selecting a cricket team going only by who the last match’s top scorers were. Just because a player or fund had a great performance once doesn’t mean they will replicate that in the next outing. Market momentum rotates. Sectors that outperform in one cycle may underperform in the next. Similarly, investment styles—whether growth, value or momentum—can fall in and out of favour based on macroeconomic cues.

A reality check using real data

Let’s examine a real-world two-year comparison of five mutual fund schemes to understand just how drastically performance and rankings can change:

Rolling returns, however, afford a more nuanced and reliable analysis.

Rather than relying on annual rankings or “best performer” lists, investors should evaluate mutual funds through a comprehensive and strategic lens. Here are the key factors that truly matter:

Final thoughts

Past performance is a rearview mirror—it reflects but cannot guide. Mutual fund rankings constantly shift because market conditions are always evolving. What did well last year might not even be in the top 50 the next. Instead of chasing high returns and names that dominated recent charts, focus on what truly builds wealth—consistency, suitability and discipline. Use rolling returns, analyse risk-adjusted metrics, and select funds that align with your goals and temperament. In the long run, successful investing isn’t about finding last year’s winner. It’s about choosing a strategy that can win across years.

The writer is a certified financial planner and founder, True North Finance, a financial and investment planning firm based in Pune.

Disclaimer: The views expressed by experts on Moneycontrol are their own and not those of the website or its management. Moneycontrol advises users to check with certified experts before taking any investment decisions.

Discover the latest Business News, Budget 2025 News, Sensex, and Nifty updates. Obtain Personal Finance insights, tax queries, and expert opinions on Moneycontrol or download the Moneycontrol App to stay updated!

${res.must_watch_article[0].headline}

Stock Market Holiday MI vs RR Live Score Jammu Kashmir News Live GST Collections in April Heatwave in India Q4 Results 2025 Live WB Madhyamik Result SSLC Result 2025 Kolkata News IPL Points Table 2025

Business Markets Stocks India News City News Economy Mutual Funds Personal Finance IPO News Startups

Home Currencies Commodities Pre-Market IPO Global Market Bonds

Home Loans up to 50 Lakhs Credit Cards Lifetime Free Finance TrackerNew Fixed Deposits Fixed Deposit Comparison Fixed Income

Home MC 30 Top Ranked Funds ETFs Mutual Fund Screener

Income Tax Calculator EMI Calculator Retirement Planning Gratuity Calculator

Stock Markets

News18 Firstpost CNBC TV18 News18 Hindi Cricketnext Overdrive Topper Learning

About Us Contact Us Advisory Alert Advertise with Us SupportDisclaimer Privacy Policy Cookie Policy Terms & Conditions Financial Terms (Glossary) Sitemap Investors

You are already a Moneycontrol Pro user.